Tomorrow is the start of the academic year at the University of Cambridge. A new intake of Divinity Faculty students will be considering whether to take courses in ethics and philosophy of religion taught or overseen by Dr James Orr, and Faculty members will find themselves sitting alongside him on committees. Orr was recently forced to step down as head of policy for Reform UK, and is currently implicated in a Met Police investigation, triggered by alleged criminal breaches of electoral law as reported by Channel 4 news. In my view, his continued presence as an active Faculty member is untenable. This is the text of a letter I wrote on 8 September 2026 (lightly edited) calling on the university to suspend Orr immediately for creating a high risk of harming the welfare of students and faculty and bringing the university into serious disrepute. I have received no reply. There is still time for them to do the right thing.
“To:
Vice-Chancellor, University of Cambridge, and Chair of Faculty Board, Faculty of Divinity
I write with deep alarm about the recent media revelations concerning Dr James Orr’s external political activities.
I am not on the staff of the Divinity Faculty but an external ‘member’, which means I respond to occasional requests for supervision, examining, admissions advice, or seminar presentations.
I care deeply, first, about the public reputation of the Faculty, of which it has been my privilege to be associated with and to serve since 2007. I want to be able to continue to feel confident in advising potential students to apply to what has been one of the premier faculties of theology and religious studies in the world. As of today, I cannot.
I write, second, out of concern for the internal flourishing of the Faculty and the morale of its staff, some of whom are colleagues and friends, and that of former students known to me who are dismayed and appalled at what is being reported.
Third, I write out of a concern for the welfare of current students many of whom, I am reliably informed, are even more dismayed and appalled at the alleged behaviour of one of their teachers.
I am aware, as undoubtedly you are, of a wide range of other allegations concerning Dr Orr’s activities both outside and inside the university (as reported in, for example Financial Times and Byline Times), but I confine myself here to the matters contained in the C4 report.
In my judgement, the Faculty and university are now suffering considerable and mounting reputational damage as a result of the highly credible allegations of criminal behaviour, in the form of breaches of electoral law, reported in the recent Channel 4 News programme about Dr Orr’s fundraising activities for Reform UK, and at greater length in the Verbatim Investigations film on which C4 drew (VERBATIM). In the C4 report, a former Electoral Commissioner declared himself to be ‘shocked’ by what he saw and said that some of the activities of Dr Orr there reported seemed on their face to be plainly illegal. In the Verbatim film, a senior lawyer was even more forthright in asserting that he judged they were clearly breaches of the law. It is at least very clear to any viewer that Dr Orr regarded some of his fundraising activities as needing to be concealed from public view.
It is, of course, not for the university to determine whether breaches of the law have occurred. It may be that the Electoral Commission and or the police will investigate; I hope they do.
It is, however, for the university, and the Faculty, to act so as to protect not only their reputations, but also the morale and welfare of Divinity Faculty staff and students, in the light of these very serious and damaging allegations, even though they concern activities outside the terms of Dr Orr’s university contract. The allegations constitute, inter alia, significant grounds for suspicion that Dr Orr has brought the university and Faculty into serious disrepute.
Even if Dr Orr ends up being cleared of any illegal activity, his stated expectation of being able to ‘get away with’ [such] behaviour, and his contemptuous disregard of the Electoral Commission as ‘dumb and ineffective’, reflect a disposition that is unacceptable in any member of the university, let alone a teacher of religion tasked with supervising students on ethics.
I am aware that Dr Orr has denied any wrongdoing, for example in a video interview published shortly after the C4 report. I can only say that I am further appalled at the complete lack of awareness on his part even of the reputational risk his activities have caused not only to Reform UK but to the university, not to mention the absence of any hint of contrition or regret.
All of this cannot but be profoundly unsettling for the whole Faculty.
In my judgement, the required action must now include immediate suspension of Dr Orr from his Faculty position until the university’s own investigations (such as they are), and those of any official bodies, are completed. I am not familiar with the relevant employment law or the content of the university’s faculty contracts, but I would be surprised if the university did not retain the legal authority to suspend a staff member at high risk of causing such massive external reputational damage and substantial internal anxiety.
Every day that this is delayed merely compounds the damage already done. It is surely untenable for Dr Orr to continue to perform his Faculty duties as if these allegations were not causing serious disturbance to multiple stakeholders, most of all students and Faculty colleagues, especially as a new term commences.
I urge you to take the necessary action as soon as possible. I hope you will not be deterred by the possible threat by Dr Orr of legal action against his critics (on which I gather he has form), likely backed by supporters with deep pockets. The institution must bravely face down such threats, real or implied.
I would welcome a reply, and am open to any corrections to anything I have written in this letter which, at this stage, is not public.
Yours sincerely
Dr Jonathan Chaplin
PS I drafted this before the news came out this evening [8/9/26] that the Met are indeed launching an investigation. In the light of this, can there be any justification for any further delay in taking the suggested action?”


Well done, Jonathan!